| Date | Opponent | Location | Time/Score | Read More |
| Mar. 5, 2009 | RENSSELAER | WRIGHT STADIUM | L, 4-17 | Box Score |
| Mar. 7, 2009 | Fredonia State | Fredonia, NY | L, 1-16 | Box Score |
| Mar. 11, 2009 | Oneonta State | Oneonta, NY | L, 3-23 | Box Score |
| Mar. 19, 2009 | Skidmore | Saratoga Springs, NY | L, 7-16 | Box Score |
| Mar. 24, 2009 | OSWEGO STATE | WRIGHT STADIUM | L, 10-22 | Box Score |
| Mar. 29, 2009 | #15 STEVENS | WRIGHT STADIUM | L, 5-20 | Box Score |
| Apr. 4, 2009 | OHIO WESLEYAN | WRIGHT STADIUM | W, 9-7 | Box Score |
| Apr. 10, 2009 | Alfred | Alfred, NY | L, 8-13 | Box Score |
| Apr. 11, 2009 | RIT | Rochester, NY | L, 5-14 | Box Score |
| Apr. 15, 2009 | UTICA | WRIGHT STADIUM | L, 7-16 | Box Score |
| Apr. 18, 2009 | NAZARETH | WRIGHT STADIUM | L, 8-15 | Box Score |
| Apr. 19, 2009 | ST. JOHN FISHER | WRIGHT STADIUM | L, 5-18 | Box Score |
| Apr. 23, 2009 | Wells | Aurora, NY | W, 16-11 | Box Score |
| Apr. 25, 2009 | Ithaca | Ithaca, NY | L, 8-19 | Box Score |
| Apr. 26, 2009 | Elmira College | Elmira, NY | L, 12-13 OT | Box Score |
